Best 4 Slice Toasters 2025 Ukulele. Enjoy bagels, bread, hot waffles, and more with our pick of the best toasters for 2025. Here are all the winners from my testing process:

Across the board, the lowest setting barely warmed the bread and imparted no color, while the highest setting toasted bread to unappetizing shades of dark brown or, worse, set off the smoke alarm. But, first you’ll need that toaster.